$B!ZE/3X@l=$650wDs6!![(B


$B0KF#K.Ip!!9V5A!V8=Be$K$*$1$kE/3X$N2DG=@-$r$5$0$k!W(B
$B6bMK(B1$B8B!!3XIt(B2$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B

$B!!(B21$B@$5*$NE/3X$O$I$3$X8~$+$*$&$H$7$F$$$k$N$+!#2J3X5;=Q$N6C0[E*$JH/E8$d@/<#7P:Q$N%0%m!<%P%k2=$K$h$C$F!"(B20$B@$5*$NBeI=E*$JE/3X$NN.GI$O$9$G$K$=$NM-8z@-$r<:$C$F$$$k$H$$$($k$@$m$&!#8=Be$NE/3XE*;W9M$ru67$H$7$F!"0lJ}$K$O0l@Z$N?M4VO@$d7A<)>e3X$r2J3XE*CN<1$X$H2r>C$7$h$&$H$9$kJ}8~$,$"$j!"B>J}$K$O$"$i$f$k2ACM$d?.G0$N:,5r$rJ82=$KAjBPE*$J$b$N$H$9$kAjBPu67$N$J$+$G!"E/3X$N
$B%F%-%9%H!&;29MJ88%!'%W%j%s%HG[I[!#(B



$B0KF#K.Ip!!FC
$B?eMK(B1$B8B!!3XIt(B2$B!A(B4$B2s@8!&1!@8BP>](B

$B!!3XLd$H$7$F$N0e3X$O<+A32J3X$HE/3X$NCf4V$H$$$&@-3J$r$b$C$F$$$k!#0e3X$O?M4V$N?HBN$H?4$r2J3XE*$K8&5f$9$k@8M}3X$d?4M}3X$r4^$_$D$D!"!V@8$H;`!W!V7r9/$HIB!W!V?HBN$H?4!W$J$I$N4QE@$+$i!V?M4V$H$O2?$+!W!V$o$l$o$l$N@8$N2ACM$H$O2?$+!W$r$D$M$KLd$o$6$k$r$($J$$!#$3$N$H?4!W$NLdBj!"!V@:?@$N@5>o$H0[>o!W$N6hJL!"!VB!4o0\?"$H?M3J$NF10l@-!W$NLdBj$J$I$r8!F$$7$F!"0e3X$K$*$1$kE/3XE*;W9M$N=EMW@-$r3NG'$9$k:n6H$r9T$&!#(B
$B!!9V5A$N%l%Y%k$O=iJbE*$J$b$N$H$9$k!#(B


$B=P8}9/IW!!FC
$B2PMK(B5$B8B!!3XIt(B3$B!A(B4$B2s@8(I%$B1!@8BP>](B

$B!!8=Be$N?tM}E/3X$K$*$1$kMM!9$J%H%T%C%/!"6qBNE*$K$O!"C4Ev650w$,8&5f$r?J$a$F$$$k!"2J3XE* $B!!!V2J3XE*'$9$k!V3hF0 $B!!$^$?!VE}7W3X$NE/3X!W$K$D$$$F$O!"!VE/3X $B!!$5$i$K!VElMN;WA[$NHs8EE5O@M}2re$2$^$9!#$3$l$O!"C4Ev650w$,O@M}3X $B!!$$$:$l$K$7$F$bO@M}$d?t3X$K4X$9$kM=HwCN<1$O$[$H$s$II,MW$"$j$^$;$s!#J,$+$i$J$$$3$H$O!"$=$N>l$G$I$s$I$sJ9$$$F$/$@$5$$!#$3$A$i$b$G$-$k8B$j$H$3$H$s@bL@$7$^$9!#(B
$B!!$^$?R2p$7$F!"3'$G5DO@$r$9$k$H$$$&%9%?%$%k$G$9!#$J$N$G!"Bg3X1!@8(I%$B3XIt3X@8$rLd$o$:!"@Q6KE*$J
$B%F%-%9%H!'(B
(1)$B=P8}9/IW!V3hF0 (2)$BF1!VE}7W3X$+$i8+$?%/%o%$%s$N2J3XO@!W!"!X%"%k%1! (3)$BF1!V8=Be2J3XO@%+%s%HIw!=D61[O@E*$G%"%W%j%*%j$JL?Bj$O2J3X$K$*$$$FB8:_$9$k$+!W!"!XM}A[!Y(Bvol.663$B!"(B(1999)
(4)$BF1!V%M%*(I%$B%Y%$%8%"%K%:%`$K$h$k5"G<$N@5Ev2=$OL$40$G$"$k!W!"!X2J3XE/3X!Y(BNo.33$B!"(B(2000)
(5)$BF1!V$5$$$OEj$2$i$l$?$N$+!=3NN(O@$N1~MQ$NHcH=E*8!F$$H2J3XE*7P83$ND61[O@@-!W!"!XE/3X8&5f!Y(Bvol.576$B!"(B(2003)
(6)$BF1!VNW>2$+$i$NLd$$!=!VE}7W3X$NE/3X!W=x@b!W!"!X5~BgJ83XIt5*MW!Y(Bvol.44$B!"(B(2005)
(7)$BF1!V??L7=bE*0l85O@!=8e4|@>C+E/3X$N:FJT@.(B($B>e(B)($B2<(B)$B!W!"!XE/3X8&5f!Y(Bvol.585/586$B!"(B(2008)
(8)Yasuo Deguchi, Jay Garfield & Graham Priest, 'The Way of Dialetheist: Contraditions in Buddhism', Philosophy East & West, (2008)
(9)Yasuo Deguchi & Katsuhiko Sano, 'Kegon Arithmetic', in press


$B=P8}9/IW!!1i=,!V8=BeE/3X1i=,!W(B
$B?eMK(B4$B8B!!3XIt(B3$B!A(B4$B2s@8!&1!@8BP>](B

$B!!8=BeE/3X$K$*$1$k=EMW$JO@J8$rFI$s$G$$$-$^$7$g$&!#(B
$B!!:G=i$Ke$2$k%F%-%9%H$O(BIan Hacking(2002)$B$G$9!#1Q8l7w$H%U%i%s%98l7w$K$^$?$,$j9-$$(B $BJ,Ln$G3hLv$9$k%O%C%-%s%0$N!VK\2;!W$,5M$^$C$?E/3XO@J8=8!#3F>O$4$H$KC4Eve$2$FA44,DLFI$rL\;X$7$^$9!#(B
$B!!$*$N:GBg$N7A<)>e3X
$B%F%-%9%H!&;29MJ88%!'(B
Ian Hacking, Historical Ontology, Harvard U.P., (2002)
David Lewis, On the Plurality of Worlds, Blackwell, (1986)



$B0KF#(I%$B=P8}!!1i=,!JB4O@1i=,!K(B
$B6bMK(B2$B8B!!3XIt(B3$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B

$B!!;0!$;M2s@80J>e$rBP>]$H$7$F!"E0Dl$7$FB46HO@J8:n@.$N;XF3$r9T$&!"$$$o$P!VE/3XF;>l!W$G$9!#(B
$B!!A04|$G$O!"E/3X$NO@J8$NFI2rNO$r?H$K$D$1$k$?$a$N%F%-%9%H9VFI$H!$B4O@$N=q$-J}$N;XF3$r9T$$$^$9!#$A$J$_$K9VFI$N%F%-%9%H$O1Q8l$G$9!#$^$?B4O@:n@.$N;XF3$G$O!"!V$=$b$=$bO@J8$H$O2?(B?$B!!46A[J8!"?M@84Q$NI=L@!"J87]I>O@!";(46E*%(%C%;%$$H$O$I$3$,0c$&$N(B?$B!W$+$iOC$r5/$3$7!"E/3XO@J8$N=q$-J}!"B($A!"E/3XE*$J5DO@9=@.K!$N%(%C%;%s%9$rEA $B!!8e4|$O!"A04|$G=,$C$?$3$H$N$l$,!"$=$N;~E@$G$G$-$F$$$kB4O@$NAp9F$NH/I=$r9T$$$^$9!#$=$l$KBP$7$F$O!"C4Ev650w$d=P@J$,4s$;$i$l$k$G$7$g$&!#IaCJ$OCgNI$/$F$b!"$$$65DO@$H$J$l$P!"1sN82qP$9$k!#%9%]!<%D%^%s%7%C%W$K$b;w$?E/3X$N5DO@$N:nK!$r!"$=$N%(!<%9%H$H$H$b$K!"$3$l$^$??H$K$D$1$F$$$?$@$-$?$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B
$B!!$3$N$9$kB>@l=$(I%$BB>3XIt$NJ}$N=P@J$bBg$$$K4?7^$7$^$9!#(B

$B%F%-%9%H!&;29MJ88%!'=i2s$N


$B0KF#(I%$B=P8}(B$B!!1i=,!JBg3X1!1i=,!K(B
$B6bMK(B3$B!&(B4$B8B!!1!@8BP>](B

$B!!Bg3X1!@8$K$h$k8&5fH/I=$N1i=,!#Bg3X1!@8I,=$!#(B



$B0KF#(I%$B=P8}(I%$BCfH*(I%$B@nE:(I%$BJ!C+!!9VFI!VE/3X!&@>MNE/3X;KF~Lg!W(B
$B7nMK(B3$B8B!!3XIt(B2$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B






$B!ZB>@l=$Ey650wDs6!![(B


$B5WJF6G!!FC
$B2PMK(B4$B8B!!3XIt(B3$B!A(B4$B2s@8!&1!@8BP>](B

$B!!(B18$B@$5*1Q9q$NE/3XR2p$7$J$,$i!"%R%e!<%`$NG'<1O@$N0U5A$H2DG=@-$r8!F$$9$k!#(B

$B%F%-%9%H!'(B
David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, edited by D.F.Norton & M.J.Norton, Oxford U.P., 2000
$B;29MJ88%$O


$BIZED63I'!!1i=,!V(BJohn Locke, An Essay Concerning Human Understanding$B$rFI$`!W(B
$BLZMK(B3$B8B!!3XIt(B3$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B



$B?\F#71G$!!1i=,!V(BFriedrich Nietzsche, Die frohliche Wissenschaft$B$rFI$`!W(B
$B7nMK(B4$B8B!!3XIt(B3$B!A(B4$B2s@8(I%$B1!@8BP>](B

$B!!(BF. $B%K!<%A%'(B(1844-1900)$B$N!XL{2w$J3X!J1Y$P$7$-CN<1!K!Y(B(1882)$B$NBh;M=q$r@:FI$9$k!#F1=q$O%K!<%A%'$NCf4|;WA[$+$i8e4|;WA[$X$N66EO$7$H$7$F0LCV$E$1$i$l$k$,!"FC$K$=$NBh;M=q$G$O8e4|$N=EMW;WA[$,$"$kDxEYB7$$F'$_$7$F$$$k46$,$"$j!"$=$N0UL#$G$b=EMW$J$b$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B!!e$NLdBjDs5/$r5a$a$k$H$$$&7A$G!"?J$a$k!#(B

$B%F%-%9%H!'%W%j%s%H$7$FG[I[!#%K!<%A%'$K6=L#$,$"$k?M$O$I$NHG$G$b$h$$$N$G!"86K\$rF~$^$7$$!#(B
$B;29MJ88%!'


$BLpEDIt=S2p!!1i=,!VO@M}3X1i=,!W(B
$B2PMK(B4$B8B(B


$B;32<=$0l!!8l3X!V%.%j%7%"8lJ8K!!J#2;~4V%3!<%9!K!W(B
$B6bMK(B1$B8B(B


$BCf@n>O!!8l3X!V%i%F%s8lJ8K!!J#2;~4V%3!<%9!K!W(B
$B6bMK(B3$B8B(B





$B!ZE/3X4pACJ82=3X7O%<%_%J!<%k![!!"*%9%1%8%e!<%k$O(B$B$3$A$i(B$B$+$i(B


$B?y;3Bn;KB>!!9V5A!VE/3X4pACJ82=3X7O%<%_%J!<%k-5!'E/3X4pACJ82=3XF~Lg!W(B
$BA04|?eMK(B1$B8B!!3XIt(B1$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B


$BDaED>0H~B>!!9V5A!VE/3X4pACJ82=3X7O%<%_%J!<%k-6!'E/3X4pACJ82=3XF~Lg!W(B
$BA04|LZMK(B2$B8B!!3XIt(B1$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B


$B5HBt0lLiB>!!9V5A!VE/3X4pACJ82=3X7O%<%_%J!<%k-7!'E/3X4pACJ82=3XF~Lg!W(B
$B8e4|?eMK(B1$B8B!!3XIt(B1$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B


$BEDCfH~;RB>!!9V5A!VE/3X4pACJ82=3X7O%<%_%J!<%k-8!'E/3X4pACJ82=3XF~Lg!W(B
$B8e4|LZMK(B2$B8B!!3XIt(B1$B!A(B4$B2s@8BP>](B